Sample Sentinel Report: Public Service Assistant

A compact coherence review of intentionally drifted implementation evidence against the curated Public Service Assistant source-of-truth packet.

Coherenceincoherent

Approval readinessNot approval-ready

Approval blockers6

Review inputs

Source packet (authority)

Public Service Assistant curated source files (2): ai-design-principles.md and public-service-request-feedback-triage-assistant-behavior-spec.md.

Evidence repo

mesh-sentinel-public-service-sample — intentionally drifted sample implementation.

Review configuration

Goal: spec-to-repo · Depth: compact · Mode: repo_coherence · Coverage: evidence_reserved.

Packet

2 source files · 7 repo evidence files · 17,148 reviewed characters.

Finding areas

Approval / escalation boundary violation

Auto-closing urgent cases violates the approval/escalation boundary. The source packet requires urgent, safety, harm, repeated-unresolved, or escalation cases to go through human review or escalation.

src/triage.js

Restricted case-history leakage

Restricted case-history details are exposed in user-facing output, and the response implies a hidden record exists. The source packet forbids exposing restricted related-case details to public users.

src/caseHistory.js

Weak inference routing

Weak keyword inference routes cases without a clarification or review step, and reports high confidence regardless of match strength. The source packet requires weak or ambiguous classifications to ask for clarification or route for review.

src/routing.js

Missing confirmation before submission

AI-generated summaries are marked ready to submit without user confirmation, even after material restructuring. The source packet requires user review or confirmation before submission.

src/summary.js

Missing behavior-boundary tests

Tests miss critical behavior-boundary coverage. The suite covers happy paths only and does not test the urgent-approval boundary, restricted-case leakage, weak-inference routing, or confirmation-before-submission boundary.

tests/

Caveat

This is a compact live-demo report. Files are budgeted and truncated for a synchronous review. It is intended to demonstrate Sentinel's review behavior, not replace a full audit.